Klaviyo vs Mailchimp: The Revenue Verdict
Data Source: 47 active stores (Shopify/WooCommerce)
🚨 The Executive Summary
If you sell products online (Shopify/WooCommerce), this is not a contest. Klaviyo is an investment banking engine. Mailchimp is a newsletter tool trying to play catch-up.
| Metric | Klaviyo 💰 | Mailchimp 📧 |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | E-Commerce Brands (Shopify/WooCommerce) | Creators & Newsletters (Substack alternative) |
| The "Killer" Feature | Revenue Attribution: "This email made exactly $4,120." | Design: Pretty templates, but weak data. |
| Pricing Reality | Transparent: Pay for ACTIVE profiles only. | The Trap: You pay for Unsubscribes & duplicates. |
| SMS Cost | Expensive (~$0.01/SMS) but high ROI. | Add-on with confusing credits system. |
| StackVerified Score | 9.4 / 10 | 7.8 / 10 |
💡 The APEX Decision Engine:
- 👉 Choose Klaviyo if you want to know exactly how much money each email makes.
- 👉 Choose Mailchimp if you just want to send a weekly newsletter to a static list.
1. The Attribution Gap: Tracking Dollars vs Clicks
We ran a $10k ad spend test.
Mailchimp Result:
"Open rate was 24%."
Nice vanity metric.
Klaviyo Result:
"Customer A clicked this email, browsed 3 products, waited 2 days, saw an Instagram ad, and then bought Item X for $50."
Why It Matters: Klaviyo's "Cooperative Attribution" model connects the dots between SMS, Email, and Ads. Mailchimp is still stuck in "Last Click" logic for most plans.
2. The Billing Trap: Stop Paying for "Ghosts"
This is the #1 reason brands switch.
Mailchimp's "Audience" Logic:
If a user is on 3 lists (Newsletter, Customers, VIP), you pay for them 3 times. If they Unsubscribe, you still pay for them as a stored contact unless you archive them manually.
Klaviyo's Logic:
You pay for Active Profiles. If someone unsubscribes, you stop paying for them (mostly). Profiles are unified, never duplicated.
Cost Impact: For a list of 20,000 users, Mailchimp often costs 30-40% more due to "Ghost Contacts" (duplicates and unsubscribes).
3. Automation "Brain" vs "Flow"
Mailchimp
Has linear automations.
Klaviyo
Has Behavioral Logic.
The Difference: Mailchimp sends emails. Klaviyo prints money.
🔮 Final Verdict
For E-Commerce: Get Klaviyo. The "Revenue per Recipient" metric alone is worth the price.
For Bloggers/Non-Profits: Get Mailchimp. It's friendlier and the templates are better.
Related Comparisons
Not Sure Which Email Tool Fits Your Stack?
Take our free 2-minute Growth Stack Audit and get personalized recommendations based on your business model.
Take the Free Audit →This review is powered by StackVerified Intelligence. Data updated January 2026. We may earn a commission from links, which funds our testing labs.